The Buffalo Bills enter Saturday’s AFC Divisional Round playoffs against the Denver Broncos facing an unprecedented challenge at the WR position. With their sights set on an AFC Championship Game appearance, the team is grappling with the fact they’ll have a limited number of receivers available for the game.
Injuries struck the Bills hard during their 27-24 Wild Card victory over the Jacksonville Jaguars, leaving them with a huge mess to figure out before the matchup in Denver. And the shortage couldn’t come at a worse time, with the Broncos boasting one of the NFL’s best defenses and homefield advantages.
The Bills, who relied on a balanced attack to secure their playoff berth, now face the prospect of over-relying on Allen’s arm and legs, potentially exposing him to more hits in the thin air of Mile High.
Still, the Bills’ path forward hinges on adaptation, making this playoff tilt not just a test of talent, but of resilience and ingenuity.
The Cascade of Bills’ WR Injuries
The Bills’ WR troubles didn’t materialize overnight. It began with Joshua Palmer’s ankle injury, which landed him on IR just before the Jaguars matchup, robbing the team of a reliable slot option who contributed 42 receptions for 612 yards in the regular season.
Gabriel Davis, who was expected to be a big-play maker, had been regaining form after a previous ACL tear, only to suffer the same fate in his repaired knee in the Jags’ game.
Shavers’ injury added insult to injury, quite literally. The young WR, who had been elevated from the practice squad, tore his ACL on a special teams play but gutted out the rest of the game, earning praise from McDermott for his toughness.
Earlier in the season, the Bills released Elijah Moore and dealt with Curtis Samuel’s extended absence, turning what was once a deep group into an extremely-thin unit. This series of misfortunes highlights the fragility of NFL rosters, especially in the grueling playoff push.
These setbacks have left Buffalo with only three healthy WRs: Khalil Shakir, Keon Coleman, and Brandin Cooks.
While the situation is dire, there are glimmers of hope. Samuel, sidelined since early November with an elbow injury, had his 21-day practice window opened recently and could potentially dress for the game.
Defensive tackle Ed Oliver is also set to practice after a biceps issue, providing a boost on the other side of the ball.
Shakir, Coleman, and Cooks Need to Step Up
With the roster whittled down, the burden falls on Shakir, Coleman, and Cooks to carry the load. Shakir, the shifty slot receiver, led the team in receptions this season with 78 catches for 912 yards and six touchdowns, proving his reliability in traffic, which will be needed against Denver’s secondary.
Rookie sensation Keon Coleman brings size and contested-catch ability, standing at 6’4″ and hauling in 45 passes for 710 yards despite missing time with injuries. His red-zone abilities led him to four touchdowns this season, making him a prime target for Allen in scoring situations.
The seasoned-veteran Cooks was acquired midseason, and what a move that has turned out to be. Cooks adds speed and experience, with his 4.33-second 40-yard dash still a weapon at age 32.
Together, this trio must build some chemistry on the fly, potentially incorporating more two-WR or 2-TE sets, utilizing tight ends like Dawson Knox and Dalton Kincaid, the latter of whom is questionable with a knee issue but expected to play a larger role.
How Will It Work vs the Broncos?
Facing a Broncos defense that thrives on pressure and coverage, the Bills may pivot to a run-heavy approach, leaning on James Cook and Allen’s mobility to control the clock and open play-action opportunities.
We can probably expect creative formations, jet sweeps, and screens to maximize the limited WRs’ strengths while minimizing mismatches.
Defensively, the Bills’ front seven, bolstered by Oliver’s potential return, could disrupt Broncos quarterback Bo Nix, who threw for 3,800 yards but struggled against elite pass rushes.
Yet, with Allen’s history of playoff magic, this game could defy expectations. A Bills win would be a testament to depth and determination, while a loss might give this front office some reasoning to have conversations on what changes could be made.